Gallstones — When Surgery Is the Right Answer

Do silent gallstones need surgery?

Most gallstones are silent. They show up on an ultrasound ordered for another reason — abdominal pain, a routine check, a screening for fatty liver. The first question most patients ask is: do I need surgery now?

The honest answer is: usually not. Asymptomatic gallstones in an otherwise healthy adult do not need to be removed prophylactically. We watch.

When surgery enters the conversation

Surgery enters the conversation when symptoms enter the conversation. Right upper-quadrant pain after fatty meals, jaundice, fever with chills, or repeated bouts of acute cholecystitis change the calculus entirely. At that point the risk of a complicated emergency outweighs the risk of an elective laparoscopic cholecystectomy.

We also operate sooner when the stones sit in a high-risk pattern — a porcelain gallbladder, very large stones (>3 cm), a polyp larger than 1 cm coexisting with stones, or a patient who would not tolerate an emergency presentation well (diabetics, the immunocompromised).

The operation, and the one decision that matters most

Laparoscopic cholecystectomy is now routine — four small incisions, day-care or a one-night stay, back to desk work in a week. The longer conversation is whether ERCP is needed first to clear stones that have migrated into the common bile duct. That single decision changes the operative plan and is where an experienced hepatobiliary surgeon adds the most value.

If you are weighing this decision, the question to ask your surgeon is not *can you do the operation* but *should it be done now, and in what sequence*.

Book a consultation or contact the chamber nearest you.